Critical Review

Critical Review — Falling Blocks: Banked Clears

• Reviewed: 2026-08-16
• Reviewer model: GLM 5.2 via the Experiments ByJTT Agent (temperature 0, independent of builder)
• Builder model: GLM 5.2 via the Experiments ByJTT Agent
• Objective verification: 7/7 checks passed + 56/56 suite + 12/12 independent harness

Process & bias controls

Independent critic, fresh context, temperature 0, under the ByJTT Gauntlet (Principle 10: execution-based review). The real game.js and test suite were reconstructed verbatim into the sandbox and executed — no claim taken on trust. The reviewer also wrote an independent stress suite probing the twist's defect class.

Verdict: KEEP — ships (7.8/10)

Average 7.8 ≥ 7.0 gate; 7/7 deterministic checks PASS, 0 FAIL. The first experiment produced entirely by the orchestrator pipeline: research → build → review.

Scores

• correctness: 9/10
• fidelity: 8/10
• twist: 8/10
• ux: 7/10
• mobile: 8/10
• accessibility: 6/10
• performance: 9/10
• security: 9/10
• docs: 5/10
• originality: 9/10

Full evidence trail below (loaded from review/review.md).